Measles Vaccine Reduces Death From Other Infections Too — By Preventing ‘Immune Amnesia’

Original post from Forbes


Tara Haelle Tara Haelle  Contributor  I offer straight talk on science, medicine, health and vaccines.full bio →

If there were ever any doubt that measles is a dangerous disease, astudy published in the journal Science yesterday blows that misconception away by finally explaining how large-scale measles vaccination caused such a plummet in childhood deaths – even from infections that seemed unrelated to measles.

Aside from the risk of death and disability that measles itself poses, the disease has another sneaky trick that scientists suspected but had trouble showing: it gives the immune system amnesia. By making the immune system forget how to fight past infections, measles throws the doors wide open for all those illnesses to visit again now that the body can’t immediately remember how to defeat them.

The measles vaccine then, in addition to preventing measles, actually prevents dozens of other infections that otherwise might occur even after a person recovers from measles. And that means widespread measles vaccination protects a community not only from measles but from other diseases as well.

Scientists had already known that measles infections suppressed the immune system for several weeks to several months, just as cancer and some other diseases do. While the immune system is beaten down, opportunistic infections such as pneumonia or diarrhea can wreak havoc on a person’s body even after they’ve recovered from the measles itself.

But there were hints that measles did more than suppress the immune system for a couple months, hints that became especially apparent after widespread vaccination. As lead author Michael Mina, an evolutionary biologist at Princeton University, and his colleagues explain in their paper, mass measles vaccination was wildly successful in reducing deaths – perhaps suspiciously successful since the drop in deaths that correlated with the vaccine’s introduction included those from non-measles infections. While advances in medical treatment and hygiene might appear to play some role in this drop, the correlation between non-measles infectious disease deaths and the vaccine’s introduction was too strong to ignore.

“They were trying to figure out just how and why measles vaccination had such long-lasting benefits and protection beyond simply preventing an active measles infection – how did it protect kids from other infectious diseases as well?” explained Tara C. Smith, an infectious disease researcher at Kent State University.

So they developed mathematical models to more closely examine deaths from non-measles infections before and after the introduction of the measles vaccine in four high-income countries: the U.S., England, Wales and Denmark. “They found that when measles infections were reduced, that led to a decrease in deaths from other infectious diseases as well – for up to three years,” Smith said. “They concluded that this was due to an effect of the measles virus itself, which they suggest causes the body to, in essence, ‘forget’ some of the immunity it has developed against other diseases.”

A doctor’s assistant applies a band-aid after vaccinating 11-month-old Tijana against measles, rubella, mumps and chicken pox on February 26, 2015 in Berlin, Germany. (Photo by Sean Gallup/Getty Images)
A doctor’s assistant applies a band-aid after vaccinating 11-month-old Tijana against measles, rubella, mumps and chicken pox on February 26, 2015 in Berlin, Germany. (Photo by Sean Gallup/Getty Images)

Other recent research had already tested the idea that this immune memory loss occurred after measles infections. Researchers created the same immunosuppressive conditions in macaque monkeys that a measles infection creates and found that the disease-fighting white blood cells basically forgot how to fight much of anything besides measles.

The researchers’ mathematical modeling was precise enough to calculate that the memory-wipe from measles infections lasts an average 27 months. Data showing infectious disease deaths occurring within a window of a few years after measles infections supported this finding as well.

“Studies like this are tough to do, but they purposely picked an outcome that was easily measurable – death – rather than something that would be more difficult to find in historical records, such as illnesses,” Smith said. “The three different countries and databases they chose all support the findings, even though measles vaccines were introduced in the UK and US in the 1960s but not until the 1980s for Denmark, so that rules out a simple worldwide trend that may have been occurring in the mid-century.”

Further, the researchers looked for similar patterns from pertussis and didn’t see the same effect.

“They have multiple controls that suggest this really is just an effect of the measles virus, and therefore prevented by the vaccine,” Smith said. “The data fit in with previous studies that have seen this effect (but they weren’t sure of the cause), and with others that looked specifically at immune responses following measles infections, so it looks fairly convincing.”

In a sense, then, you could think of the MMR as protecting against more than just measles, mumps and rubella. It protects against those three diseases as well as all the others that might have come along had a person not been protected from measles.

“Our results show that when measles was common, measles virus infections could have been implicated in as many as half of all childhood deaths from infectious disease,” the authors wrote. “The reduction of measles virus infections was the main factor in reducing overall childhood infectious disease mortality after the introduction of vaccination.” Further, because vaccination provided a population (herd) immunity against measles, that meant that, in effect, “measles vaccination might also be preserving herd protection against non-measles infections.”

Eliminating measles with the vaccine is a triple win: less measles, less death from other diseases in individuals and less infections overall within a highly vaccinated population.

The incredible power of the measles vaccine, in 3 graphics

Original post from The Washington Post

‘…………By Ana Swanson

Sometimes we take the benefits of modern medicine for granted, but a small dose of data and history can easily remedy that. The chart below, created by Valentine Svensson, a PhD student in molecular biology at Cambridge University, shows the dramatic decline in the incidence of measles in 20th century America.

You can see that the incidence of measles fell sharply after the vaccine was introduced in 1963, only 50 years ago. As the vaccine did its work, the incidence of measles dropped to zero by the end of the century. (The left-hand axis is graphed as a base 10 log, a common technique that statisticians use to bring in spread-out values and illuminate a trend.)

Lest we forget where we came from, here’s a map that shows how deadly measles was in 1880. The map shows the ratio of deaths from measles to aggregate deaths, based on the tenth census ever conducted in this country. The graph at the lower left hand corner of the page shows how the states compared in terms of deaths by measles, while the key at the bottom right hand corner of the page tells you how many deaths the different shaded areas correspond to. (Click on the map, which is republished courtesy of the David Rumsey Historical Map Collection, to enlarge.)

In most states, fewer than 30 deaths per 1,000 were due to measles, or less than 3 percent of overall deaths. In some parts of Georgia, Nebraska, Colorado and Kansas, however, that proportion reached 3-6 percent of deaths, while in New Mexico it topped 6 percent of all deaths.

Finally, here’s a graphic showing how measles spreads in an area without a vaccination program, by Bonnie Berkowitz and Lazaro Gamio of The Washington Post. The differently shaded squares represent four generations of infection, from Patient Zero (the darkest red square at the top left) to the people he or she infects (the next 17 reddish squares), the people they infect in turn (the next five lines of peach-colored squares), and the people they infect (the rest of the graphic). The dark squares represent the people who die from measles.

Without vaccinations, each measles case will infect 12 to 18 other people on average every 10 to 14 days. You can see how quickly the disease spreads from the first generation (Patient Zero) to 12 to 18 people in the second generation, 144-324 people in the third generation, and 1728-5832 people in the fourth generation. That adds up to more than 6,000 infections, all within 40 days. In a country with substandard healthcare and malnutrition, up to 28 percent of those infected will die.

Now contrast that with a country with full vaccination: In that scenario the disease would spread to 0.8 people every 10 to 14 days, and less than .3 percent will die. In a country like the United States, where most people have been vaccinated but pockets have not, the disease would spread to 1.1 to 2 people every 10-14 days and less than .3 percent would die.

More posts from Know More, Wonkblog’s social media site:

Where America’s uninsured, untreated, mentally ill live

Map: Where Americans are dying before their time

The terrifying rise of diabetes, in every corner of the U.S.

     Ana Swanson writes for Know More and Wonkblog.  ………….’